IndianCAs by Ashwin Nagar: December 2021

22 December 2021

Statistics: Viewers of this blog were

Sanjay Nikam, Ankit Agarwal and Ketan Saiya crosses quota at elimination of Jayesh Kala.

Ishwar Jivani crosses quota at final elimination of Abhishek.

Here is the final position:

Register for CRED and get upto 250 cash back.

Hi! I am sending you upto Rs. 250 (minimum ₹100) towards your credit card bill this month. Sign up on CRED (official sponsor of IPL) using this link and claim a cashback and other rewards when you make your first payment. Hurry, this link of CRED expires in 48 hours.

CRED Link

ICAI has notified results of Central Council

Here is the official link

ICAI Notification

RCM: Results of Regional council is known now and names of 21 winner is final.

With elimination of Kamlesh, the regional council is final now. Jayesh Kala is being eliminated but it is just academic exercise as Abhishek sitting at no. 22 will not get anything which can jump him above Ankit Rathi. Jayesh will make Mumbai candidates strong. Only ranking will change, Few will achieve quota and distribution will happen, but the final 21 remain the same as are those sitting at the top 21 rank at this moment.

So congratulations to all 21 elected RCMs

RCM: Status after elimination of Kamlesh Saboo

Status after elimination of Kamlesh Saboo

Murtuza Kachwala hit the quota.

21 December 2021

RCM: Status after elimination of Vijendra Jain, Kamlesh Saboo will be eliminated tomorrow

RCM: Status after elimination of Shardul Shah. Vijendra Jain is being eliminated.

CCM: Piyush Elimination Complete.

Piyush elimination count :

Durgesh Kabra - 467
Dhiraj - 514
Vishal - 141
Mr. Adukia - 467
All achieved quota
Vishal elected at 11

We will stop providing any further update on Central Council.

Thank you all.

RCM: Status after elimination of Pradeep Kabra

Here is the status after Pradeep.

RCM: Status after elimination of Rajesh Agarwal Pune

Status after elimination of Rajesh Agarwal Pune. Pradeep Kabra elimination is in progress.

CCM: What next on CCM counting process today?

What next on CCM counting process today?

Is this result final?

There are similar questions people still admin. Let me charity on this.

All 11 candidates elected are final and no changes.
Only academic process left for Central Council results, Piyush Chhajed will be eliminated, all excess of Aniket and Purushottam will be distributed.
The outcome of this will change the sequence in which candidates are declared elected.
The elimination of Piyush may change the ranking or order, but not the results.
Those in top 11 will be declared elected even if they don't reach quota under election rules.
This doesn't make difference to anyone. Once elected everyone is equal CCM.

RCM-Can Shilpa Shingare still survive?

On the chart at this moment, it falsely appears Shilpa will be next to be eliminated after Rekha, because Rajesh will move up after elimination of Rekha Dhamanakar. But that's untrue. Shilpa needs only 50 to 80 votes from Rekha to jump the ladder up and sit above Pradeep Kabra and Vijendra Jain, and that she will surely get. So next elimination by all probability will be of Pradeep Kabra from Surat and the Surat will rest it's case for the third seat, which was never expected after Ishwar and Abhishek.

RCM: Would Pune get 3rd seat?

Regional Results: Would Pune get 3rd seat?

Rekha's elimination will decide this. Rekha will give lots of votes to fellow Pune contestant Rajesh Agarwal and Rajesh seen at the moment at 28th will jump up. How much and would he be able to survive the onslaught of later Mumbai elimination is the key to see whether Pune gets its 3rd seat after Yashwant and Ruta.

20 December 2021

Aniket and Purushottam cross the quota on elimination of Hardik.

Finally the magic no. for both Ahmedabad candidates after elimination of Hardik Shah from Surat. Both crossed quota. Aniket got 448 votes, Purushottam got 264 votes and Vishal Doshi got 235 votes.

Breaking: Rajkumar Adukia and Vishal Doshi won the crucial battle. Piyush Chhajed lost

Rajkumar Adukia and Vishal Doshi won the crucial battle. Piyush Chhajed lost in the roller coaster ride of this election process.

CCM: Status after elimination of Hardik

Breaking: Vishal moves down to 11, Purushottam moves up to 6

Changes after Vishnu's elimination.

Vishal moves down to 11 Purushottam moves up to 6
Piyush Chhajed moves down to 10
Dheeraj moves up and above Durgesh at 8
Durgesh Kabra moves up to 9

Status after elimination of Vishnu

Here is the status.

Recount has been asked by Piyush

A recount has been asked for Mangesh's surplus which has completely turned the game by Piyush Chhajed.

Below is status after excess distribution of all who crossed quota and got elected.

Breaking:Durgesh moves ahead of Dhiraj after all sub parcels of Shrinivas distributed

Durgesh moves ahead of Dhiraj after all sub parcels of Shrinivas distributed.

Why sitting Central Council members are struggling and losing. Only 1 out of 5 CCM elected so far is sitting member being re-elected.

This is really interesting to note that only 1 out of 5 members elected so far is a sitting member getting re elected to the council. If you look at the first preference votes, in top 5, there was not a single sitting CC member. There are 2 sitting CC member already eliminated and 2 are still struggling to be in comfortable position.

What it indicates. May be COVID impacted their performance and visibility or may be people have much more expectation than in past from them, as all the new comer and mufasil man doing far better and people see great potencial in them to deliver on their issues at the ground level.

Now distribution of excess from there candidates who just crossed quota will further prolong process

As 3 candidates got elected by elimination and stands above quota of 4131 and the surplus numbers needs to be distributed to tally our Balance Sheet. Remember we are CAs and keep all records perfectly howsoever complex it may be.

Now distribution of excess from there candidates who just crossed quota will further prolong process and wait for few desperate and borderline candidates will increase. The increase in adrenaline and anxiety has one more day before culmination.

Breaking: Chandrashekhar Chitale from Pune crosses quota and elected..

The sub parcels of votes from elimination of Shrinivas Joshi has enabled three quota crossings and election. Chandrashekhar Chitale from Pune has been re elected with flying colours as expected and crossed quota after Shrinivas elimination. Umesh Sharma and Mangesh already crossed quota from seconds from Shrinivas.

Chitale got 495 from 5 sub parcels and reached to 4220. Please not there are many more sub parcels to be distributed.

Rank	Name	EL of Anil	After Anil
1	Savla Priti Paras	-	4,131
2	Patodia Sunil	-	4,131
3	Sharma Umesh	145	4,075
4	Kinare Mangesh	52	3,919
5	Khandelwal Purushottamlal	87	3,772
6	Talati Aniket	89	3,739
7	Chitale Chandrashekhar	78	3,704
8	Doshi Vishal	66	3,056
9	Chhajed Piyush	153	2,811
10	Khandelwal Dheeraj	144	2,718
11	Kabra Durgesh	186	2,675
12	Adukia Rajkumar	155	2,521
13	Shah Hardik	32	2,503
14	Agarwal Vishnu	131	2,358
15	Joshi Shriniwas	66	2,255

Status after All parcels inclduing sub parcels of Drushti

Rank	Name	EL of Drushti	After Drushti
1	Savla Priti Paras	-	4,131
2	Patodia Sunil	-	4,131
3	Sharma Umesh	47	3,930
4	Kinare Mangesh	62	3,867
5	Khandelwal Purushottamlal	19	3,685
6	Talati Aniket	69	3,650
7	Chitale Chandrashekhar	76	3,626
8	Doshi Vishal	151	2,990
9	Chhajed Piyush	120	2,658
10	Khandelwal Dheeraj	128	2,574
11	Kabra Durgesh	156	2,489
12	Shah Hardik	45	2,471
13	Adukia Rajkumar	169	2,366
14	Agarwal Vishnu	63	2,227
15	Joshi Shriniwas	140	2,189
16	Bhandari Anil	117	1,944

IndianCAs by Ashwin Nagar